Changing Parenting Orders

Parenting Legal

I want to change the Parenting Orders. Can I do this?

The Rule in Rice v Asplund

As far as possible the court aims to make parenting orders final.

Given the unpredictability of life finality is not always possible. In many cases new orders are necessary and/or desirable. There are two ways this can be achieved.

  1. If both parents agree on the changes to be made they can formalise this by way of a Parenting Plan which will over-ride the existing Court Orders; or
  2. If the parties are not in agreement then, after mediation has been attempted, an application can be brought to the Court. The court will only entertain varying existing orders if the rule in Rice v Asplund (1979) FLC 90-725 is satisfied.

Simply put the rule in Rice v Asplund is that a court should not entertain an application to change a previous parenting order unless there has been a significant change in circumstances or there was some material factor not disclosed at the earlier hearing, which would justify “such a serious step”.

The test in Rice v Asplund is a ‘threshold test’ therefore if the court is not satisfied that the test has been passed the original orders will not be altered.

It should be noted that even if this ‘threshold test’ is overcome and the application to vary the orders is heard there is no guarantee that the orders will be changed. The matter will be dealt with in the same manner as it previously was and the best interests of the child will be paramount. It does not follow that the best interests of the child will not still be met by the existing orders even though there has been a significant change in circumstances since they were made.

An example of the successful application of the rule occurred in the case of Morton v Berry [2014] FamCAFC 208. On appeal it was found that the expressed wishes of a child (10 years old) in circumstances where that child had not expressed a wish in the earlier proceedings were significant and the case was remitted for rehearing.

Subscribe for all of the latest resources

Rli Samantha@2x
Samantha Miller

Samantha has been a lawyer since 2001 having followed in the steps of her father, grandfather, great-grandfather and great-great-grandfather. No one can say she didn’t know what she was getting into!

Initially admitted in 2001 as a solicitor in NSW and Australia, Samantha moved to the UK where she was admitted as a solicitor in England and Wales in 2002. After working in several different areas of the law in large London firms, she determined that family law was her calling and hasn’t looked back.


Oap Close
Not in Newscastle, no problem
online consulations available

Share This

Select your desired option below to share a direct link to this page